As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Links to Amazon below are affiliate links. We never show prices because they change, so check the current price on Amazon.
Condition is most of a card's value. A few pounds of the right supplies keeps a good card good, and the wrong binder can quietly ruin it.
A soft "penny sleeve" is the first layer. It stops surface scratches and fingerprints. Put the card in top-first, gently, and don't force it.
Fits Pokémon, One Piece and Magic cards. Buy a big pack, since you'll use more than you think.
A top loader is a rigid plastic holder. Sleeve the card first, then slide it in. This is how most collectors store and post good cards. Standard top loaders fit a sleeved standard-size card.
35pt is the normal thickness for a standard card in a penny sleeve.
Binders are great for collections you want to look at, but choose carefully:
Look for 'side loading' and 'PVC free' in the description.
Cheaper cards don't need sleeves. Stand them upright in a proper card storage box, not loose in a shoebox, so the edges don't get bent.
Cardboard 'count' boxes are cheap and stack neatly.